Musharraf is
best bet for the
United States
By Hassan
Abbas
2/14/2002
Reprinted from
The Boston Globe
To be head of
state in
Pakistan is
dangerous. A
majority of
those who have
held the post
entered the
office in glory
and fanfare but
left either in
humiliation or
in coffin.
Whether the
Pakistani
president,
General Perves
Musharraf, will
be able to
escape this
trend is a moot
point. A lot
would depend on
the responses of
India and the
United States to
his recently
adopted
policies.
Musharraf
must learn from
history. Liaquat
Ali Khan,
Pakistan's first
prime minister,
was assassinated
because
influential
elements in the
establishment
were becoming
wary of his
policies.
Zulfiqar Ali
Bhutto, the
country's most
popular
political
figure, was
hanged after a
highly
controversial
court judgment
because the
internal and
external powers
to be considered
him too
dangerous.
General
Zia-ul-Haq lost
his life in a
mysterious air
crash.
Pakistan
today is passing
through the most
crucial phase of
its checkered
history. Though
its intelligence
agencies'
misadventures
and the failures
of its political
leadership are
still haunting
the country,
Musharraf has
displayed ample
courage and
acumen since
Sept. 11, not
only rescuing
Pakistan's
battered
international
image but
improving its
viability as a
state as well.
Historically,
military regimes
have played a
damaging role in
economic
development and
democracy in
Pakistan, but
Musharraf is
proving to be
different.
During a recent
visit to
Pakistan, I
interviewed some
of his friends
and foes.
One friend,
who has known
him since they
both joined the
military academy
more than three
decades ago,
told about a
couple of
miraculous
escapes
Musharraf had
during his
military career,
showing how
lucky he has
always been.
When I asked
a former
Pakistani
general about
his views on
Musharraf, he
said, ''He is a
weak-hearted
general who was
exposed during
the Kargil
episode in
1999'' - when
Pakistani
soldiers seized
mountain heights
in Kashmir -
''and US picked
him for the
slot, as such a
person suits
them.'' Farooq
Adam Khan, a
Pashtun and the
former
prosecutor
general of
Pakistan's
National
Accountability
Bureau, said,
''The path opted
by Musharraf
vis-a-vis
Afghanistan is a
pragmatic one
but not an
honorable one.''
Hamid Mir,
the journalist
who interviewed
Osama bin Laden
last November
and is writing
Osama's
''authorized''
biography, told
me that bin
Laden spent
considerable
time during the
interview
arguing that it
is incumbent
upon ''good''
citizens of
Pakistan to
eliminate
Musharraf.
Interestingly,
prominent
political
leaders, such as
Salman Taseer of
the People's
Party and
Khawaja Asif of
the Muslim
League,
irrespective of
the official
stance of their
parties, were
full of praise
for Musharraf,
especially for
the bold steps
he took recently
to tackle
religious
fanaticism and
terrorism. But
there is also a
general
perception in
Pakistan that
the United
States is not
doing enough to
support Pakistan
economically or
in seeking a
resolution of
the conflict
between India
and Pakistan
over Kashmir.
In fact,
Pakistan's
intelligentsia
seems convinced
that India is
talking war with
the tacit
approval of the
United States.
It is argued
that the war
talk is being
done so that
Musharraf
''continues to
obey.''
Musharraf's
steps to crack
down on
extremists are
not a post-Sept.
11 reaction. He
was publicly
vocal against
the Jihadi
mullahs prior to
the attacks. The
only difference
now is that he
has the
requisite
justification to
clamp down on
their
activities.
Musharraf's
campaign against
extremists will
succeed because
Pakistanis are
tired of
fanatics who
created havoc in
the country,
especially in
terms of violent
sectarianism.
Still, he may
not survive for
long if the
Kashmir issue
remains
simmering or if
there is any
compromise on
the country's
nuclear
capability.
Crucial
institutions are
being
''cleaned,'' but
public opinion
has its own
dynamics. If
Pakistan is
calling off
support to
militancy in
Kashmir, India
should also be
''convinced'' to
stop state
terror in the
disputed land.
Musharraf, in
the prevailing
circumstances,
is not only the
best bet for
Pakistan but
also for the
United states.
Without proper
nurturing, it
won't take very
long for hope to
turn into
despair. |